Welcome or Register

Martha's Vineyard Top Rated Restaurants

 This list is taken from TRIPAVISOR which lists the Islands top No. 1-30 rated Restaurants.  Of course, there are many others that you can also find on the Island as well with other web searches.  Please visit the restaurants personal website before visiting to make sure you are finding the right dining experience for your specific tastes-- as some of these restaurants listed below range from more traditional and formal dining to very casual, some that are pubs and taverns with loud music, to specific cuisines and foods, and a few with only outdoor seating.   


 EDGARTOWN RESTAURANTS

 AMONG THE FLOWERS CAFÉ
(AMERICAN) 
“Lovely Little Café”  “Best Breakfast”

 SEAFOOD SHANTY   
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD/SHUSHI)  ($10-$30)
“Love the deck views” “Great Food!” 

 NEWS FROM AMERICAN PUB   
(AMERICAN/BRITISH/PUB)  ($20) 
“Fun Pub in Edgartown” “Good News” 

 LUCKY HANK’S RESTAURANT & CAFÉ   
(AMERICAN/VEGETARIAN)  ($10-$40)
“Good little Rest”  “Hank’s spot was great!”  

 ATRIA 
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD)
“Good dining experience, I would go back” “Dreamlike Lobster”

 ISOLA 
(ITALIAN)
“Best Pizza!”  “Wonderful Experience”

 THE TERRACE AT THE CHARLOTTE INN  
(AMERICAN/FRENCH/INTERNATIONAL)  ($28-$60)
“Delicious meal!” “One of the best dining experiences”

 L’ETOILE 
(FRENCH/AMERICAN/CONTEMPORARY)  ($50)
“Great date night atmosphere”  “A truly romantic French Restaurant”

 WHARF PUB & RESTAURANT  
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD/PUB)
“Great Dinner and View”  “Something for everyone”

 CHESCA’S RESTAURANT   
(ITALIAN) 
“Popular Edgartown Rest” “Fine Dining”

 THE RIGHT FORK DINER
(AMERICAN)  ($4-$25)
“Not a typical diner!” “Best Diner on the Island”

 THE PORT HUNTER  
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD)
“Fun, Great Atmosphere” “Nice Night Out!” 
 

 OAK BLUFFS RESTAURANTS
 

 MARTHA’S VINEYARD CHOWDER COMPANY  
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD)   ($12-$40)
“Fantastic Food”  “Warm and Quiet”

 RED CAT KITCHEN AT KEN’S N’ BECK 
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD/CONTEMPORARY)  ($20-$60)
“Just Perfect” “Best of the Vineyard” 

 OFFSHORE ALE COMPANY   
AMERICAN/PUB/PIZZA)  ($25)
“Went for the beer and Oh, my Goodness, Great experience!”   

 LINDA JEAN’S RESTAURANT  
(AMERICAN)
“Yummy” “Great local eats!” 

 NANCY’S RESTAURANT   
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD) ($5-$30)
“Great lunch” “Great sunset on the deck”

 20BYNINE   ($8-$20)
(AMERICAN/PUB)
“Wonderful Food” “Great for drinks and Apps”

 SLICE OF LIFE
(AMERICAN/PIZZA)
“Great!” “Fresh & Sweet” 

 LOOKOUT TAVERN
(RAW BAR/AMERICAN/SUSHI/JAPANESE/PUB)
“Great Bar Scene”  “Loved this place in Oak Bluffs”

 GIORDANO’S RESTAURANT & CLAM  
(ITALIAN/PIZZA)  ($10-$20)
“Great Food” “Delicious Lobster Ravioli!” 

 SHARKY’S CANTINA 
(MEXICAN)  ($7-$19) 
“Great lunch!” “Good overall fun place” 


 VINEYARD HAVEN
 

 ARTCLIFF DINER
(AMERICAN)
“Great food & Service!”  “Best Breakfast I ever had”

 THE NET RESULT
(JAPANESE/SEAFOOD/SUSHI)
“Something fishy is going on!”  “Good Food”

 COPPER WOK   ($7-$15)
“Great Value on the Vineyard”  “Good dining option”

 BLACK DOG TAVERN  
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD/PUB)  ($21-$30)
“Comfortable and a view of the water!” “Outdoor seating and also Breakfast”


 WEST TISBURY
 

 STATE ROAD RESTAURANT  
(AMERICAN)  ($25-$55)
“If you ever get the chance to dine here, you will love it.”  
“President Obama and Michelle visited and loved it.” 

 MENEMSHA
 

 LARSEN’S FISH MARKET
(AMERICAN/SEAFOOD)  ($15) 
“Hot lobster rolls!”  “Eat on lobster cages!” 

 MENEMSHA FISH MARKET
(SEAFOOD/AMERICAN)
“Delish” “Good Lobster Rolls!” 

Guest Reviews

THE VINEYARD HOUSE - "This is our ninth consecutive summer coming to the Vineyard. Since renting the Katama House in 2007 we stopped renting elsewhere. All the Bonnetti houses are perfectly appointed for a great family vacation. The houses are cheerfully decorated, comfortable, clean and in a great Katama location."
The Surfside Cottage - This was the 3rd year renting from Sandra and Paul. Such a great location! Such lovely people. There is everything you could ask for In a vacation rental and if you need something just ask I am certain they will do their Best to accommodate you. Look forward to renting from them Again! Edwina & Don Amorosa 9/1-9/30
Surfside - "We had such a lovely stay at the Cottage House! My husband and I stayed on the Vineyard for our wedding and honeymoon and we couldn't have picked a better place to stay. The house was beautiful, and just so peaceful and comfortable." N/A 2016
View All